Irritatingly Repetitive
"Having seen the interview of the authors of this book on the PBS, given my own concerns over the incessant attacks on science, and on truth in general, over the past decade, I decided to purchase this book. Regrettably, despite their deeply personal experiences as victims of the Far Right’s anti-science campaign, I was rather disappointed by their presentation of the subject matter. First, whereas the authors are to be commended for their research of the groups and individuals who have been waging the current war on science, I found their book to be exceedingly repetitive; in my opinion, the entire book could easily be summarized into a ten-page magazine article. Their incessant hammering of the same points was a seriously irritating experience for me. Second, whereas I would have expected a “history” of the attacks on science since at least the period of Ancient Greece, other than a passing mention made of Galileo, the authors chose to focus solely on the most recent period. In my opinion, this was a missed opportunity. Third, and this is rather damning, whereas the authors abundantly exposed the Far Right’s attacks against science, they remained conspicuously silent on the attacks from the Left, particularly those from the Woke movement which denies the very existence of science, treating it as derived from a male-dominated, colonialist, white-nationalist, misogynist, homophobic, Islamophobic, Fascist culture and mind-set; not even a peep concerning the attacks from the Ultra Left! Fourth, while the following represents only a minor digression from the central theme of the book, I was rather irritated by the authors’ choice to suggest that Justin Trudeau’s political career was a victim of Vladimir Putin’s attacks on science : (1) I found this side discussion to be truly bizarre and not even remotely related to the central theme of the book, (2) as for many tyrants, Vladimir Putin is a pragmatist and, as his regime benefits from science, it is an unjust cheap-shot to characterize this otherwise despicable man as being anti-science, and finally, (3) it is a gross exaggeration to suggest that Vladmir Putin hastened Justin Trudeau’s political demise; nope, Wonder Boy did it to himself! The authors should stick to science and refrain from the temptations of political analysis. Fifth, as this book is purportedly a professionally-prepared treatise of a serious matter, I found the authors’ authors’ stylistic choice of referring to each others’ professional colleague by their chatty first names rather than by their academic titles to have a diminishing effect on the tone and seriousness of the subject matter. Style DOES matter!"